Food Fraud Advisors

You are here: Home / Archives for Horizon Scanning

by

Food Fraud Databases Compared

Updated 29 January 2023

A food fraud database is a collection of information about food fraud incidents and food fraud risks. There are paid and free databases operated by governments, not-for-profits and private companies.  The type of data varies from database to database, as does the cost and the features.

Pay-To-Use Databases

There are four well-known, pay-to-use food fraud databases.  Since 2020, company mergers, acquisitions, and name changes have made it hard to understand which database is which – and which one is best for you.  The four best-known commercially operated databases are listed below.

(1) EMAlert by Battelle.  This database has been around for many years, but no longer has a high profile.  It still exists, but contains information for only a limited number of commodities.  https://www.emalert.org/

(2) HorizonScan (FERA).  This tool was developed by the UK government’s Food and Environment Research Agency (FERA). It is widely used and includes alert systems and information about food safety, food fraud and suppliers.  https://horizon-scan.fera.co.uk/

(3) Decernis’ Food Fraud Database (formerly the United States Pharmacopoeia (USP) Food Fraud Database).  The Decernis Food Fraud Database includes scholarly articles on testing and detection methods as well as food fraud incidents.  https://decernis.com/products/food-fraud-database/

(4) Agroknow’s FoodAkai is the most recently developed tool.  It uses sophisticated AI to analyse data from global food safety agencies to offer insights into hazards in raw materials, ingredients and products.  Like HorizonScan, it includes food safety as well as food fraud issues and incidents.  https://agroknow.com/foodakai/

FoodChainID is another big name in food fraud tools and they also list a product called HorizonScan™ on their website.  Confusingly, FoodChainID’s HorizonScan™ is the same as FERA HorizonScan.  The difference is in the regional distribution rights for each product.  FoodChainID – a company – distributes the HorizonScan product in the USA.  FERA distributes it in non-US markets.

FoodChainID also has a partnership with EMAlert and recently bought the company Decernis, which owns the (formerly USP) Food Fraud Database.  This makes FoodAkai the only well-known paid tool that is independent of FoodChainID.

A less well-known paid service is MerieuxNutriSciences’ Safety HUD, which monitors official agencies and other sources for alerts on food safety and frauds. Safety Hud 2.0 | Food Compliance Solutions (mxns.com)

Costs

There is a notable lack of transparency in the pricing of food fraud databases.  Fees to access the databases are usually levied on a subscription basis.  The cost varies depending on the number of users and whether you are a consultant or a single food company.

All the databases listed above offer either a free trial or a guided demonstration, so you can compare them to decide which might be best for your company’s needs.

Affiliation

Food Fraud Advisors has no financial relationships with the products or companies listed here, though we do have contacts at each organisation, so if you would like a no obligation introduction, just ask. We do not earn a commission from such introductions.

Free Databases

(1) Food Fraud Advisors’ Food Fraud Risk Information Database (hosted on Trello) is a free and open-access online database of food fraud incidences and emerging threats, organised by food type.  No log-in required.  https://trello.com/b/aoFO1UEf/food-fraud-risk-information

(2) FoodSHIELD is a US Government-Academic partnership.  Access to the FoodSHIELD food fraud and food defense database is limited to representatives from local, state, and federal governments, the military and laboratories that perform analyses.  https://www.foodshield.org

(3) Food Protection and Defense Institute (USA)’s Food Adulteration Incidents Registry. Access by special request only. https://incidents.foodprotection.io/about

(4) Rapid Alert System for Food and Feed (RASFF) is managed by a group of European national food safety authorities and alerts its member states to incidences of food and feed safety and integrity.  RASFF publishes a searchable database for investigating incidences of food fraud.  To learn more about RASFF click here.  For direct access to the database, open the RASFF Portal.

(5) US FDA’s Recalls and Food Safety Alerts, has a searchable database and includes incidents arising from food fraud.  http://www.fda.gov/Safety/Recalls/

(6) MEDISYS for Food Fraud (MEDISYS-FF) is a food fraud media monitoring system that uses information from the Europe Media Monitor to collect media reports related to food fraud.  The reports can be filtered by country of origin, keyword and date.  You can request access to the system by submitting a form.  https://bigdata-wfsr.wur.nl/2020/09/18/medisys-for-food-fraud/ 

Which Database Should I Use?

How do I know which database will meet my needs?

 

What are your needs? Check the headings below to see which best describes your company’s needs for food fraud information. 

 

Low budget and/or need information infrequently

If you have a low budget and don’t need to access information often, Decernis’ Food Fraud Database has cost-effective single month or month-to-month subscriptions.

Custom alerts for specific ingredients or foods

All four paid databases allow you to create custom alerts for products, ingredients of interest.  You receive an email or other notification when a new incident occurs.

Food safety and food fraud alerts

HorizonScan and FoodAkai both include food safety hazards as well as food fraud hazards in their reporting and alert systems.

Analytical test methods information

Decernis’ Food Fraud Database includes test method information and research papers.

Large number of users across multiple sites

If you have a high number of users who want to access the database or a very large number of products, HorizonScan and FoodAkai have enterprise-level subscriptions so users on different sites can set up their own reports and alerts.

Predictions about future hazards

FoodAkai promises early warning of emerging risks, which are predicted using AI technology. The makers of FoodAkai say their software predicted the multi-country, multi-product ethylene oxide in sesame recall disaster of 2020-2021.

Students, occasional needs, non-food professionals

The Food Fraud Information Database hosted on Trello is a great place to start your food fraud journey if you are a student or new to the food industry.  It is free and contains good summaries of the types of food fraud that affect various foods.  However, it is not easily searchable (you can buy a searchable ‘snapshot’ in Excel form) and it does not provide custom alerts.  Incidents added to the database are mostly drawn from international media and are heavily weighted to English language media, so are not suitable for accurate counting or mapping of incidents.

Other free information about European and North American foods

RASFF (Europe) and FDA Recalls and Food Safety Alerts (USA) mostly contain food safety incidents, with few food fraud incidents.  Much of the data derives from cross-border food movements, especially in RASSF.  They are both free and searchable and can be a useful adjunct to the free food fraud database on Trello.

 

by

Future and emerging threats of food fraud

Food fraud: you don’t want it.

  • If you are manufacturing, wholesaling or retailing food or beverages, fraudulent activities within your supply chain pose risks to your brand and to your customers.
  • Different food types vary in their susceptibility to food fraud.
  • The risks change over time.
  • Purchasers of food and food ingredients must remain vigilant about new and emerging risks.
  • The requirement to monitor emerging and predicted food fraud issues is a part of all major (GFSI) food safety standards.

Learn how to monitor food fraud threats here.

by

Food Fraud News – May 2017

European food supply at risk from climate change affects on other continents

A study that examined European water demand found the EU to be likely to be affected by droughts in other countries because of its reliance on certain food crops that do not grow in Europe.  They predicted that droughts in growing areas for almonds, pistachios, grapes, rice, soybeans and sugar cane would have serious impact on European supplies and prices.  Droughts are expected to occur more frequently with climate change.  The largest impact is expected to be on the European meat and dairy sector due to its reliance on soy for animal feed.  Increasing prices and factors that affect supply can increase the risk of food fraud, with food and feed that is imported from drought affected countries likely to become more vulnerable.

Condiments and sauces; counterfeiting operations, products uncovered more frequently

Another counterfeit condiment operation has been uncovered in Asia in recent months.  This follows an earlier discovery, in January this year of a sophisticated factory complex in China that was manufacturing a range of sauces and noodles and packing them with counterfeit branding for Maggi, Knorr and Nestle.  Fifty small factories were hidden in a residential area, and managed to produce goods worth $14.5 million per year, according to one estimate.  In Europe, counterfeit seasoning cubes were seized during a recent enforcement operation.  And there have been two recent incidences of salt fraud; one in Nigeria and one in Scotland.  Is condiment counterfeiting growing or are we just getting better at finding it?  Only time will tell.  What we do know for certain is that it is not only premium, luxury goods that are at risk of being copied.

Salt production, Mauritius

Coffee price volatility set to increase

Larger than usual volatility in coffee pricing is predicted for the coming year as weather events and an unusually large predicted crop of arabica in Brazil are expected to impact world markets.  In addition, the Honduran coffee harvest is at risk from a leaf mould disease.  The previous outbreak in that country had a lasting impact on the harvest.  Coffee is already at high risk of food fraud and increasing volatility in the markets in the short term is likely to increase the risk.  Long term predictions for coffee supply are already grim because of climate change’s effects on growing conditions.  Heavy disease burdens in key growing areas will exacerbate the problem and ultimately increase the supply problems worldwide, increasing coffee’s vulnerability to food fraud.

Coffee,authentic,fraud,horizon scanning
Increased volatility in coffee markets is predicted for the coming year

Vertical integration in the food supply chain in Italy

An Italian consumer group has warned that at least 5000 restaurants in Italy are run by the mafia.   The mafia in Italy are also said to be involved in food fraud within primary production, manufacturing and wholesaling sectors.  Any restaurant that is run by an organisation that has links to organisations that are perpetrating food fraud provides the perfect sales outlet for the fraud-affected food.  The foods are, in effect, exchanged for ‘clean’ currency from restaurant patrons, essentially laundering money derived from food fraud operations.  It has been reported that some of the mafia-run growing operations are being done on polluted land that is not safe for food production.

Get more news

Learn about the food fraud risks for hundreds of different products in our Food Fraud Risk Information Database, hosted by Trello.  It’s new, it’s free, check it out today.

food fraud risk database

 

 

 

by

What’s the go with garlic?

Whole fresh garlic is at low risk of fraudulent adulteration, however, as with other produce, there is a medium to high likelihood of its origin or organic status being misrepresented in markets where consumers pay a premium based on those characteristics. For fresh bulb garlic, claims about chemical treatments, such as bleaching, are also at risk of being fraudulent.

For powdered and flaked garlic, the risk profile is different.  Dried and powdered garlic are at higher risk of adulteration than whole bulbs. All types of dried, flaked and powdered garlic are at risk of undeclared preservatives or additives, undeclared fillers (diluents), such as chalk or flour, misrepresentation of organic status or origin and smuggling.  In early 2017, some food companies in USA and Australia found garlic powder that was sourced from China to be contaminated with peanut.

In October of 2016, it was reported that speculators were purchasing huge quantities of garlic in China, the world’s largest garlic exporter, after prices almost doubled in the previous year. This has led to supply issues and very high prices. Dried garlic is affected even worse than fresh bulbs.

In April 2017, CBC News (Canada) reported that garlic trading trends have food fraud expert Professor Chris Elliott mystified, because sales are at normal levels despite much of China’s recent garlic crop being devastated by a cold snap.  This might be because the speculators who were hording garlic in the previous year have been releasing it on to the market this year.

Want information just like this for hundreds of other food types?  Check out our Food Fraud Risk Information database.

Is garlic at risk of food fraud?

by

Food Fraud Risk Database

It’s huge, it’s completely free and open-access; no log-in required.  It’s our

Food Fraud Risk Information Database

Compiled by food fraud experts and containing information about hundreds of different food types, including past incidences of food fraud and emerging threats, you can use it to meet the requirements of your food safety management system, for

  • food fraud vulnerability assessments,
  • food safety risk assessments
  • hazards from intentional adulteration requiring preventive controls (FSMA)
  • pre-filtering and
  • horizon scanning for emerging threats

You can choose to ‘watch’ the database to receive notifications every time new information is added.  You can also watch individual food types (say “Beef”) to receive updates for just that food type.

Access is free, although if you want to receive notifications you will need to create a (free) Trello account.  We do not receive income from Trello for new sign-ups.

Check it out today

food fraud risk database
Food Fraud Risk Information database, created by Food Fraud Advisors, hosted by Trello.com